Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

New Milford

Breakfast

  • New York Style Bagels

    Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Pumpernickel, Egg, Cranberry, Multigrain, Oatbran, Honey Wheat, & “The Everything” each $1.50

    1/2 dozen $9

    $16 per dozen

  • Muffins, Croissants, Cinnamon Rolls, Scones & Cookies

  • *Breakfast Bagel

    Egg, Melted Cheese and either Bacon, Ham or Sausage on your favorite Bagel or Roll

    $4.65

    Turkey sausage, turkey bacon, vegan sausage, chorizo sausage $1

    Steak egg and cheese $1.50

    Hash Browns $1.35

  • Breakfast Burrito

    $6.15

  • Bagelman’s Own Cream Cheese

    Served on your choice of Bagel

    Butter $2.50

    Plain Cream Cheese $3.25

    Vegetable $3.75

    Scallion $3.75

    Olive $3.75

    Strawberry $4.25

    Walnut & Raisin $4.25

    Lox Spread $3.48

    Peanut Butter & Jelly $3.50

  • Coffee

    Iced Coffee - Iced Latté - Frappé Espresso - Latté - Cappuccino

    Flavor of the Month!

    Try a new and exciting flavor each month!

Specialty Sandwiches

  • American Combo

    Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    $9

  • Bagelman Club

    Turkey, Ham, Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    $9

  • Barney

    Peppermill Turkey, 1000 Island dressing and Swiss cheese

    $7.50

  • BLT

    Bacon, lettuce and tomato and mayo

    $7

  • Beefeater

    Roast Beef, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and horseradish sauce

    $9

  • Italian Combo

    Ham, Cappy Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar

    $9

  • Honey Dripper

    Ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard on rye

    $7.50

  • Texan

    Roast Beef, Cheddar cheese, horseradish sauce, lettuce and tomato

    $8.50

  • Times Square

    Turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on rye

    $10

  • The Classic

    Fresh Nova Lox, Cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion

    $10

  • Tuna Melt

    Tuna salad, melted cheese on an open faced bagel

    $9.50

  • Turkey Club

    Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    $9.50

Wrap Sandwiches

  • Greek Chicken

    Grilled chicken, feta cheese, red onion, black olives, lettuce and tomato with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10.50

  • BBQ Chicken

    Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, lettuce and tomato

    $9.50

  • Chicken Cheddar Ranch

    Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, lettuce, tomato, and bacon

    $10

  • Turkey Veggie Cheddar

    Turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, green peppers, ranch dressing

    $9.50

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, hot sauce, choice of either ranch or bleu cheese dressing

    $9.50

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar

    Grilled chicken, lettuce, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing

    $9.50

Panini Grill Sandwiches

  • The Russian Chicken

    Chicken Cutlet, Melted Meunster cheese, & Russian dressing

    $10

  • The Turkey Cordon Bleu

    Grilled ham and turkey, melted Swiss cheese & ranch dressing

    $10

  • The Eggplant Panini

    Breaded eggplant, fresh melted Mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers & a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10

  • The Ultimate Italian

    Your choice of Chicken Cutlet or Grilled Chicken, fresh melted Mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers & balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10

  • The Grilled Vegetables

    Fresh sautéed squash and zucchini, roasted red peppers, sautéed onions, fresh melted mozzarella cheese & balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10

 Deli Delights

Choice of White, Rye, Whole Wheat, Bagel, Roll, Wraps  
Wedges $1.50 extra

  • Roast Beef

    $8.50

  • Turkey

    $7.50

  • Salami

    $7.50

  • Ham

    $7.50

  • Pastrami

    $7.50

  • Bologna

    $7

  • Tuna Salad

    $7.75

  • Chicken Salad

    $7.75

  • Egg Salad

    $6.50

  • Seafood Salad

    $8

Hot Sandwiches

Served on Hard Rolls, Bagels, Bread, Wraps  
Wedges $1.50 extra

  • Balboa

    Roast Beef, melted Mozzarella cheese, Sautéed onions and peppers on a garlic wedge

    $10.50

  • *Big Daddy

    Bacon cheeseburger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo and ketchup

    $9

  • 8 oz. Hamburger

    $6

  • Big “D”

    Grilled Turkey, bacon & melted Mozzarella cheese, on a garlic roll

    $10

  • Chicken Cutlet Deluxe

    Breaded chicken, bacon, Cheddar cheese & 1,000 Island dressing

    $10

  • Chicken Fingers

    5 Chicken Tenders, w/ your choice of sauce

    $6.50

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Chicken Cutlet, tomato sauce and Mozzarella cheese

    $8.50

  • Chicken Philly

    Grilled chicken, sautéed onions & peppers & Cheddar cheese

    $8.50

  • Chicken Cutlet or Grilled Chicken

    $7.50

  • *Philly Steak

    Steak, Cheddar cheese, sautéed onions & peppers

    $8.50

  • N.Y. Style Reuben

    Pastrami, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut & 1,000 Island dressing on grilled rye

    $9

  • Yankee

    Breaded Chicken Cutlet, American cheese, 1,000 Island dressing, lettuce & tomato

    $8

  • Pizza Bagel

    Tomato sauce, melted Mozzarella cheese & oregano on an open faced bagel

    $6

  • Hot Wings

    10 for $12

Soup of the Day

Small or Large

Gluten Free Menu

  • Muffins

    $2.99

  • Brownies

    $4

  • Cookies

    $2.99

  • Mama’s Cheese Bread - Whole Grain Bread

    Extra to Any Sandwich $2.50

Kid’s Menu

  • Chicken Nuggets

    (6 pieces)

    $4

  • Peanut Butter & Jelly

    $3.50

  • Grilled Cheese

    $3.50

  • Mac & Cheese Bites

    (6 pieces)

    $6

Fresh House Salads

  • Tossed Salad

    Mixed green lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots

    $5.50

    w/grilled chicken, tuna, chicken or egg salad $10.50

  • Apple Walnut Tossed Salad

    Apples, cranberries, walnuts & Gorgonzola cheese

    $6.50

    w/grilled chicken, tuna, chicken or egg salad $10.50

  • Chef Salad

    $10.50

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    Romaine lettuce, croutons and Parmesan cheese

    $10.50

  • Chicken Cheddar Ranch Salad

    Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon & ranch dressing

    $11

  • Dressings - Italian, Ranch, 1,000 Island, Caesar, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette & Blue Cheese

Sides

  • French Fries

    (french, curly)

    sm $3.50

    lg $5.50

  • Bacon Cheese Fries

    sm $5

    lg $7

  • Hash Browns

    $1.35

  • Potato Salad

  • Macaroni Salad

  • Pasta Salad

  • Coleslaw

  • Bean Salad

  • Fruit Salad

  • Parfaits

  • Assorted Juices, Soda & Chips

Extras

  • Cheese

    $0.50

  • Bacon

    $3

  • Wedges & Wraps

    $2

  • Hot Peppers

    $0.75

  • Red Roasted Peppers

    $1

Breakfast

  • Special #1 - Assorted Bagels

    Your choice of cream cheeses and butter displayed beautifully on a platter

    per head $3.60

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Special # 2 -Assorted Bagels, Pastries and Muffins

    Your choice of cream cheeses and butter & jelly beautifully arranged on a platter

    per head $4.10

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Special # 3 - *Scrambled Eggs, Bacon,Sausage, Bagels and Hard Rolls

    Fluffy scrambled eggs, crisp bacon, delicious sausage and your choice of cream cheeses, butter and jelly.

    per head $9

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

Serve Bagelman Coffee at your next gathering

  • Our Coffee Set Up Includes:

    Regular & Decaf Coffee, Hot Tea includes: cups, milk, cream, sugar and sweet n’ low

    per head $2.35

    Assorted Juices (per head) $2.50

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry or eggs may increase your risk of foodbourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Cold and Hot Buffet

  • Cold Cut Platters

    Your choice of meats and cheeses. Lettuce, tomato, mustard & mayo. Bagels andhardrolls

    per head $9

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Sandwich Platter

    Sandwich Platter

    Assorted sandwiches of your choice on bagels and hardrolls. Beautifully arranged on a platter. Lettuce, tomato, mustard & mayo

    per head $8.50

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Fresh Deli Salad

    Potato salad, macaroni salad, coleslaw and pasta salad

    per head $3.25

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Sandwich Platter Combo

    Assorted sandwiches of your choice, side salads, assorted drinks and cookies for dessert

    per head $13

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • 2 to 6 Foot Giant Sub Sandwiches

    2 to 6 Foot Giant Sub Sandwiches

    Cold (per foot) $21

    Hot (per foot) $24

  • “Ask About Our Sub Sandwich Combo Specials”

  • Smoked Salmon Platter

    Fresh smoked salmon, assorted cream cheeses, lettuce, tomato, onions & assorted bagel

    per head $14

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

    *2 day notice please

Hot Food

  • Baked Ziti

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $85

  • Chicken Marsala

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $85

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $85

  • Sausage & Peppers

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $85

  • Garden Salad

    1/2 Tray $30

    Full Tray $45

  • Add Grilled Chicken

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $75

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    1/2 Tray $45

    Full Tray $75

  • Small tray serves 6 - 8 people

  • Large tray serves 12 - 15 people

Chicken Wings

  • Available in 2 sizes!

    Small (40) - $60.00 Large (65) - $85.00

Coffee On The Go!

  • Box Of Coffee

    A box of coffee, for 10 people includes cups and all the fixins!

Party Orders Welcome!

  • All items eat in or take out. Call ahead to have your order waiting for you.

  • Slide 1 of 3
  • Slide 2 of 3
  • Slide 3 of 3

    • Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.