Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Mill Plain Menu

Breakfast

  • New York Style Bagels

    Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Pumpernickel, Egg, Cranberry, Multigrain, Oatbran, Honey Wheat, & “The Everything” each $1.50

    1/2 dozen $8.50

    $16.50 per dozen

  • Muffins, Croissants, Cinnamon Rolls & Scones Cookies

  • *Breakfast Bagel

    *Breakfast Bagel

    Egg, Melted Cheese and either Bacon, Ham or Sausage on your favorite Bagel or Roll

    $5

    Steak egg and cheese $6.50

  • Breakfast Burrito

    Breakfast Burrito

    3 eggs scrambled with sausage, Tex-Mex cheese and salsa in a wrap

    $7

  • Breakfast Turkey Wrap

    Fresh Roasted Turkey, 3 Eggs, Avocado and Cheese on a Wrap

    $8.50

  • Bagelman’s Own Cream Cheese

    Served on your choice of Bagel

    Butter $2.10

    Plain Cream Cheese $2.41

    Vegetable $2.90

    Scallion $2.90

    Olive $2.90

    Garlic $2.90

    Strawberry $3.58

    Walnut & Raisin $3.58

    Lox Spread $3.58

    Peanut Butter & Jelly $3.50

  • Coffee

    Espresso - Lattes - Iced Lattes

    Flavor of the Month!

    Try a new and exciting flavor each month!

Specialty Sandwiches

  • American Combo

    Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    $10

  • Bagelman Club

    Turkey, Ham, Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on bread of your choice

    $10

  • Firehouse

    Roast Beef, Pepper Jack cheese, horseradish sauce, lettuce and tomato

    $10.50

  • Beefeater

    Roast Beef, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and horseradish sauce

    $10.50

  • Italian Combo

    Ham, Sopressata, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar

    $11

  • Honey Dripper

    Ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard on rye

    $9

  • Red Sox

    Peppermill turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    $9

  • Sloppy Russian

    Pastrami, Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Russian dressing on rye

    $9

  • Times Square

    Turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on rye

    $10

  • The Classic

    Fresh Nova Lox, Cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion

    $12

  • Tuna Melt

    Tuna salad, melted cheese on an open faced bagel

    $9.50

  • Turkey Club

    $10

Hot Sandwiches

  • Balboa

    Roast Beef, melted Mozzarella cheese, sauteed onions and peppers on a garlic wedge

    $12.50

  • T.B.S.

    Grilled Turkey, bacon, melted Swiss cheese and mayo on a wedge

    $11

  • Chicken Cutlet Deluxe

    Breaded chicken, bacon, Cheddar cheese & 1000 Island dressing on a wedge

    $12

  • Philly Steak

    Steak, Cheddar cheese, sautéed onions & peppers on a Wedge

    $11

  • Chicken Philly

    Chicken, sauteed onions & peppers & Cheddar cheese on a Wedge

    $12

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Chicken Cutlet, tomato sauce and Mozarella cheese on a roll

    $10

  • Chicken Cutlet or Grilled Chicken

    Lettuce and tomato on a roll

    $8

  • N.Y. Style Reuben

    Corned Beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and 1000 Island dressing on grilled rye

    $9

  • Yankee

    Breaded Chicken Cutlet, American cheese, 1000 Island dressing, lettuce & tomato on a roll

    $9

  • Pizza Bagel

    Tomato sauce, melted Mozzarella cheese & oregano on an open faced bagel

    $6.50

  • BLT

    Bacon, lettuce and tomato

    $7.50

  • Big Daddy

    Bacon cheeseburger, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo and ketchup on a roll

    $7.50

  • Barney

    Peppermill Turkey, 1000 Island dressing and Swiss cheese

    $9

 Deli Delights

Choice of White, Rye, Whole Wheat, Bagel, Roll, Wraps  
Wedges $2.00 extra Gluten free bread $2.50 Extra

  • Roast Beef

    $10

  • Turkey

    $8

  • Salami

    $8

  • Ham

    $8

  • Pastrami

    $8

  • Bologna

    $6

  • Tuna Salad

    $8

  • Chicken Salad

    $8

  • Egg Salad

    $7

Wrap Sandwiches

  • Greek Chicken

    Grilled chicken, feta cheese, red onion, black olives, lettuce and tomato with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $9.50

  • BBQ Chicken

    Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, sauteed onions, lettuce and tomato

    $9.50

  • Chicken Cheddar Ranch

    Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, lettuce, tomato, and bacon

    $9.50

  • Turkey Veggie Cheddar

    Turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, choice of either ranch or bleu cheese dressing

    $9.50

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar

    Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing

    $9.50

Panini Grill Sandwiches

  • The Russian Chicken

    Chicken Cutlet, Melted Meunster cheese, & Russian dressing

    $10

  • The Turkey Cordon Bleu

    Grilled ham and turkey, melted Swiss cheese & ranch dressing

    $10

  • The Eggplant Panini

    Breaded eggplant, fresh melted Mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers & a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10

  • The Ultimate Italian

    Your choice of Chicken Cutlet or Grilled Chicken, fresh melted Mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers & balsamic vinaigrette dressing

    $10

Sides

  • French Fries

    $3.50

  • Potato Salad

    $3.25

  • Macaroni Salad

    $2.75

  • Pasta Salad

    $3.25

  • Coleslaw

    $3.25

  • Fruit Salad

    $5

  • Assorted Juices, Soda & Chips

Soup of the Day

Small or Large

Extras

  • Hash Brown

    $1.25

  • Cheese

    $0.50

  • Bacon

    $2

  • Wedges & Wraps

    $2

  • Hot Peppers

    $1

  • Red Roasted Peppers

    $1.50

  • Avocado

    $2

Fresh House Salads

  • Tossed Salad

    Mixed green lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots

    $6

    w/grilled chicken, tuna, chicken or egg salad $10

  • Chef Salad

    $10

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    Romaine lettuce, croutons and Parmesan cheese

    $10

  • Apple Walnut Chicken Salad

    Grilled chicken, apples, cranberries & walnuts & gorgonzola cheese w/ a balsamic vinaigrette

    $10

  • Chicken Cheddar Ranch

    Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon & ranch dressing

    $10

  • Blackened Chicken Salad

    Blackened chicken, feta cheese and oil & vinegar

    $10

  • Dressings - Italian, Ranch, 1000 Island, Caesar, Russian, Light Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Blue Cheese & Honey Dijon

Breakfast

  • Special #1 - Assorted Bagels

    Your choice of cream cheeses and butter displayed beautifully on a platter

    per head $3.96

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Special # 2 -Assorted Bagels, Pastries and Muffins

    Your choice of cream cheeses and butter & jelly beautifully arranged on a platter

    per head $4.51

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Special # 3 - *Scrambled Eggs, Bacon,Sausage, Bagels and Hard Rolls

    Fluffy scrambled eggs, crisp bacon, delicious sausage and your choice of cream cheeses, butter and jelly.

    per head $9.90

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

Serve Bagelman Coffee at your next gathering

  • Our Coffee Set Up Includes:

    Regular & Decaf Coffee, Hot Tea includes: cups, milk, cream, sugar and sweet n’ low

    per head $1.85

    Assorted Juices (per head) $2

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry or eggs may increase your risk of foodbourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Cold and Hot Buffet

  • Cold Cut Platters

    Your choice of meats and cheeses. Lettuce, tomato, mustard & mayo. Bagels andhardrolls

    per head $8

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Sandwich Platter

    Sandwich Platter

    Assorted sandwiches of your choice on bagels and hardrolls. Beautifully arranged on a platter. Lettuce, tomato, mustard & mayo

    per head $8.50

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Fresh Deli Salad

    Potato salad, macaroni salad, coleslaw and pasta salad

    per head $3

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • Sandwich Platter Combo

    Assorted sandwiches of your choice, side salads, assorted drinks and cookies for dessert

    per head $14.50

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

  • 2 to 6 Foot Giant Sub Sandwiches

    2 to 6 Foot Giant Sub Sandwiches

    Cold (per foot) $21

    Hot (per foot) $24

  • “Ask About Our Sub Sandwich Combo Specials”

  • Smoked Salmon Platter

    Fresh smoked salmon, assorted cream cheeses, lettuce, tomato, onions & assorted bagel

    per head $12.50

    Includes plates, knives, napkins

    *2 day notice please

Hot Food

  • Baked Ziti

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $85

  • Chicken Marsala

    1/2 Tray $55

    Full Tray $90

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $95

  • Sausage & Peppers

    1/2 Tray $50

    Full Tray $80

  • Garden Salad

    1/2 Tray $25

    Full Tray $40

    Add Grilled Chicken $45 - $55

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    1/2 Tray $45

    Full Tray $55

  • Chicken Tenders

    Chicken Tenders

    1/2 Tray $45

    Full Tray $80

  • Small tray serves 6 - 8 people

  • Large tray serves 12 - 15 people

Chicken Wings

  • Available in 2 sizes!

    Small (40) - $50.00 Large (65) - $80.00

Coffee On The Go!

  • Box Of Coffee

    A box of coffee, for 10 people includes cups and all the fixins!

    $22.50

Party Orders Welcome!

  • All items eat in or take out. Call ahead to have your order waiting for you.

  • Slide 1 of 3
  • Slide 2 of 3
  • Slide 3 of 3

    • Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!